Providing an Effective Model for Monitoring and Evaluation of Public Financial Performance in Performance Based Budgeting (PBB)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 financial managment

2 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Accounting, Azad University of Central Tehran

Abstract

The main purpose of this research is to study the factors affecting the efficiency of monitoring and evaluating financial performance in the public sector in performance-based budgeting and its practical purpose is to provide appropriate suggestions and solutions to financial performance in the public sector in performance-based budgeting. The research method used in this study is mixed (qualitative-quantitative one.). First, using meta-combined qualitative analysis method, the indicators are extracted from previous articles and studies, and out of 82 articles obtained, 42 final articles were used to examine the effective factors in the efficiency of monitoring and evaluating financial performance in the public sector in the above mention budgeting. Then, by categorizing the indicators and performing fuzzy Delphi technique, the content of the design was analyzed; the main indicators were identified and screened. Then, using the several method, the criteria were prioritized and the weight of the criteria and the (13) effective factors were determined prioratively. It should be noted that the research data analysis was performed in the qualitative phase with MaxQDA software and in the quantitative phase with Matlab software.

Keywords

Main Subjects


احمدی، ر.، و محمودخانی، م. (1396). رویکرد کمیته حسابرسی در تغییر رژیم حسابداری به استانداردهای بین‌المللی گزارشگری مالی. مقاله ارائه شده در: دومین کنفرانس بین‌المللی مدیریت و حسابداری، تهران، ایران، 14 تیر 1396.
اسگندری، ک.، و کردبچه، ش. (1395). تبیین نیاز به استانداردهای حسابرسی عملکرد مدیریت در دستگاه‌های اجرایی. مطالعات کاربردی در علوم مدیریت و توسعه، 1(1)، 1-10.
الماسی، ح.، دهگان، م.، و حیدری، د. (1395). بررسی تاثیر گزارش تفریغ بودجه دیوان محاسبات کشور در اعمال نظارت بر عملکرد مالی دولت و اثربخشی بودجه‌های سالیانه. دانش حسابرسی، 16(63)، 35-62.
امامی، م.، و نادری‌باب‌اناری، م. (1386). تأملاتی پیرامون نظارت مالی بر دستگاه‌های دولتی در ایران. حقوق اساسی، 4(8)، 43-58.
امینی، م. ر.، آذر، ع.، بیات، ک.، و خدیور، آ. (1397). طراحی مدل توسعه‌یافته بلوغ بودجه‌ریزی بر مبنای عملکرد:با تأکید بر قابلیت‌ها و نتایج یک نظام بالغ. پژوهش‌های مدیریت در ایران، 22(4)، 225-247.
آذر، ع.، و امیرخانی، ط. (1397). بودجه‌ریزی عمومی: نهادهای بودجه‌ریزی و بودجه محلی. تهران: سمت.
آذر، ع.، و حبشی، ن. (1396). ارائه الگوئی موثر برای حسابرسی بخش عمومی دیوان محاسبات جمهوری اسلامی ایران. دانش حسابرسی، 17(66)، 5-40.
باباجانی، ج.، برزیده، ف.، و ایمان‌زاده، پ. (1398). ارزیابی وضع موجود حسابرسی عملکرد در نهادهای بخش عمومی ایران و ارائه راهکارهایی جهت بهبود آن. مطالعات تجربی حسابداری مالی، 15(61)، 1-26.
پریمچاند، آ.، خاکباز، ا.، و قاسمی، م. (1384). پاسخگویی مالی در بخش عمومی. مجلس و پژوهش، 13(51)، 299-333.
حساس‌یگانه، ی.، و جعفری، و. (1387). نقش کمیته حسابرسی در واحدهای غیرانتفاعی بخش عمومی. حسابدار، 23(196)، 73-77.
خدابخشی، ه.، و جباری، م. (1394). لزوم نظارت قبل و حین خرج در نظام بودجه‌ریزی مبتنی بر عملکرد. مجله اقتصادی، 15(1-2)، 53-66.
خیرالهی، ف.، کرمی، ا.، و حافظی، ف. (1394). بودجه‌بندی بر مبنای عملکرد و تاثیر آن بر عملکرد دولت. مقاله ارائه شده در: اولین همایش ملی مدیریت و حسابداری ایران، همدان، ایران، 14 آذر 1394.
رنگریز، ح.، نوه‌ابراهیم، ع. ر.، آراسته، ح. ر.، و سلطانیه، ف. (1396). طراحی الگوی شایستگی‌های استراتژیک مدیران کارکردی با استفاده از روش تحلیل مضمون. مدیریت بر آموزش سازمان‌ها، 6(1)، 9-49.
سایبانی، ع. ر.، و جعفری، ز. (1396). جایگاه نظارت مالی در قانون اساسی و بررسی آن در آرای شورای نگهبان. پژوهش ملل، 2(17)، 71-87.
ضرونی، د.، و جلالیان، ع. (1397). الگوی مطلوب نظارت مالی دیوان محاسبات. دانش حقوق مالیه، 2(4)، 39-50.
قدیری‌مقدم، ا.، و بقایی‌راوری، ج. (1386). نظری اجمالی بر حسابرسی و نظارت بر عملکرد مالی دولت و اثر آن بر اقتصاد بخش عمومی. دانش و توسعه، 177-194.
کردستانی، غ. ر.، و علوی، س. م. (1393). نقش حسابرسی داخلی در بهبود مدیریت بخش عمومی. حسابرسان داخلی، 1(3)، 28-21.
کلانترمهرجردی، ا.، قسیاری، ح.، و توسلی، ر. (1396). اثربخشی حسابرسی دولتی. پژوهش‌های جدید در مدیریت و حسابداری، 3(22).
گلدوست، م. (1390). بررسی عوامل داخلی و قانونی موثر بر بروز نارسایی در سیستم کنترل‌های مالی دستگاه‌های اجرایی [پایان‌نامه کارشناسی‌ارشد]. تهران: دانشگاه پیام‌نور استان تهران.
محمودخانی، م.، و احمدی، ر. (1397). حسابرسی عملکرد با تأکید بر بخش عمومی. حسابداری، پاسخگویی و منافع جامعه، 8(2)، 71-98.
موسوی، س. ف.، آذر، ع.، رجب‌زاده، ع.، و خدیور، آ. (1397). طراحی مدلی برای بودجه‌ریزی بر مبنای عملکرد با استفاده از ترکیب روش‌شناسی سیستم‌های نرم و نگاشت شناختی فازی و تاپسیس سلسله مراتبی فازی. پژوهش‌های مدیریت در ایران، 22(1)، 299-322.
مهدی‌فرد، م. ر.، و شعبانی، ص. (1394). شاخص‌ها و رویکردهای حاکم بر نظام نظارت مالی بخش عمومی. حسابرس، (77)، 138-144.
نخعی، ک.، حسین‌پور، م.، برزگران، ا. ر.، و خراشادیزاده، ا. (1397). بررسی تاثیر حسابرسی عملکرد در راستای عدالت و ایفای مسئولیت‌های اجتماعی دستگاه‌های اجرایی در بخش عمومی. تحقیقات جدید در علوم انسانی، 4(8)، 91-116.
نظری‌پور، م. (1396). ضرورت استقرار حسابرسی عملکرد از دیدگاه حسابرسان بخش عمومی. حسابداری دولتی، 3(2)، 79-92.
نوروزی، ح.، و سجادی، ح. (1395). حسابرسی عملکرد و ارتقاء کیفیت و کارایی فعالیت‌های دستگاه‌های اجرایی. مطالعات اقتصاد، مدیریت مالی و حسابداری، 2(1/4)، 114-133.
هدایتی‌زفرقندی، م. (1396). نقش و کارکرد دیوان محاسبات در تحقق نظارت مالی. پژوهش ملل، 2(18)، 60-45.
Acerete, B., Gasca, M., & Stafford, A. (2019). Two decades of DBFO roads in the UK and Spain: An evaluation of the financial performance. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 90(2), 269-89. [DOI:10.1111/apce.12237]
Ahmadi, R., & Mahmoudkhani, M. (2017). [Audit committee approach to changing accounting regime to international financial reporting standards (Persian)]. Paper presented at 2nd International Conference on Management and Accounting, Tehran, Iran, 5 July 2017. https://civilica.com/doc/643381/
Al-ahdal, W. M., Alsamhi, M. H., Tabash, M. I., & Farhan, N. H. S. (2020). The impact of corporate governance on financial performance of Indian and GCC listed firms: An empirical investigation. Research in International Business and Finance, 51, 101083. [DOI:10.1016/j.ribaf.2019.101083]
Al-Busaidi, S. S. M. (2018). Contribution of monitoring and evaluation to promote good governance in Oman. [MSc. thesis]. Coventry: Coventry University. [DOI:10.13140/RG.2.2.30075.62247]
Almasi, H., Dehgan, M., & Heidari, D. (2016). [Study of the impact of budget deduction report of supreme audit court in exercising supervision of government financial performance and the effectiveness of annual budgets (Persian)]. Audit Science, 16(63), 35-62. https://danesh.dmk.ir/article-1-1256-fa.html
Amini, M. R., Azar, A., Bayat, K., & Khadivar, A. (2019). [Presenting a developed Performance Based Budgeting Maturity Model: With focusing on capabilities and results in a mature system (Persian)]. Management Research in Iran, 22(4), 225-47. http://mri.modares.ac.ir/article-19-22789-fa.html
Audenaert, M., Decramer, A., George, B., Verschuere, B., & Van Waeyenberg, T. (2019). When employee performance management affects individual innovation in public organizations: The role of consistency and LMX. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 30(5), 815-34. [DOI:10.1080/09585192.2016.1239220]
Azar, A., & Amirkhani, T. (2018). Public budgeting: Budgetqry institutions and local budget (Persian)]. Tehran: SAMT http://opac.nlai.ir/opac-prod/bibliographic/5502554
Azar, A., & Habashi, N. (2017). [Provide an effective model for auditing the public sector of the Court of Audit of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Persian)]. Audit Science, 17(66), 5-40. https://danesh.dmk.ir/article-1-1490-fa.html
Babajani, J., Barzideh, F., & Imanzadeh, P. (2019). [Study of the present situation of performance audit in Iranian public sector institutions and presentation of strategies for its improvement (Persian)]. Empirical Studies in Financial Accounting, 15(61), 1-26. [DOI:10.22054/QJMA.2019.42320.2003]
Byaruhanga, A., & Basheka, B. C. (2017). Contractor monitoring and performance of road infrastructure projects in Uganda: A management model. Journal of Building Construction and Planning Research, 5(1), 30-44.  [DOI:10.4236/jbcpr.2017.51003]
Cabinet. (2014). Performance monitoring and evaluation: Principles and approach. Retrieved from https://www.dpme.gov.za/publications/Policy%20Framework/Discussion%20document%20PME%2027%20October%202014%20final.pdf
Cheng, J. H., Lee, C. M., & Tang, C. H. (2009). An application of fuzzy Delphi and fuzzy AHP on evaluating wafer supplier in semiconductor industry. WSEAS Transactions on Information Science and Applications, 6(5), 756-67. https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.5555/1558801.1558807
Chimtengo, S., Mkandawire, K., & Hanif, R. (2017). An evaluation of performance using the balanced scorecard model for the university of Malawi’s polytechnic. African Journal of Business Nagement, 11(4), 84-93. [DOI:10.5897/AJBM2016.8201]
Dabrowska, J. (2011). Measuring the success of science parks: Performance monitoring and evaluation. Paper presented at the XXVIII IASP World Conference on Science and Technology Parks, Manchester Science Parks, Manchester, UK, 18 February 2011. https://www.cmimarseille.org/sites/default/files/newsite/manupls/pdf4.pdf
de Ridder, D. T. D., Lensvelt-Mulders, G., Finkenauer, C., Marijn Stok, F., & Baumeister, R. F. (2012). Taking stock of self-control: A meta-analysis of how trait self-control relates to a wide range of behaviors. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(1), 76-99. [DOI:10.1177/1088868311418749]
Deshpande, R. (2018). Budget monitoring and oversight system in Myanmar. Retrieved from https://asiafoundation.org/publication/budget-monitoring-oversight-system-myanmar
Emami, M., & Naderi Bab Anari, M. (2007). [Reflections on financial supervision of government agencies in Iran (Persian)]. Houghough Asasi, 4(8), 43-58. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/5008/
Engela, R., & Ajam, T. (2010). Implementing a government-wide monitoring and evaluation system in South Africa. ECD Working Paper Series, 21. http://hdl.handle.net/10986/27574
Erkutlu, H. V., Tanç, Ş. G., & Koçyiğit, S. Ç. (2017). The factors used to create performance-based budgeting: A research on Turkey. In S. Gokten, (Ed.), Accounting and corporate reporting: Today and tomorrow. London: IntechOpen. [DOI:10.5772/intechopen.68920]
Esgandari, K., & Kurdbacheh, Sh. (2017). [Explain the need for management performance auditing standards in executive devices (Persian)]. Journal of Applied Studies in Management and Development Sciences, 1(1), 1-10. http://www.asmd.ir/post.aspx?id=491
Funnell, W. (2015). Performance auditing and adjudicating political disputes. Financial Accountability & Management, 31(1), 92-111. [DOI:10.1111/faam.12046]
Ghadiri Moghadam, A., & Baghaei Ravari, J. (2007). [Overview of auditing and supervision of government financial performance and its impact on public sector economy (Persian)]. Knowledge and Development, 177-94. https://profdoc.um.ac.ir/paper-abstract-1006204.html
Goldman, I., Engela, R., Akhalwaya, I., Gasa, N., Leon, B., & Mohamed, H., et al. (2012). Establishing a national M&E system in South Africa. PREM Notes, 21. http://hdl.handle.net/10986/17084
Goldoost, M. (2011). [Investigating the internal and legal factors affecting the occurrence of failure in the financial control system of executive organs (Persian)] [MA. thesis]. Tehran: Tehran Porvince Payame Noor University. https://ganj.irandoc.ac.ir/#/articles/792297c5b21ed7e970c6c6de65bbf10d
Gordon, V., Osgood Jr, J. L., & Boden, D. (2017). The role of citizen participation and the use of social media platforms in the participatory budgeting process. International Journal of Public Administration, 40(1), 65-76. [DOI:10.1080/01900692.2015.1072215]
Guzmán, M., Irarrázaval, I., & de los Rios, B. (2014). Monitoring and evaluation system: The case of Chile 1990-2014. Evaluation Capacity Development (ECD) Working Paper Series, 29. http://hdl.handle.net/10986/21313
Hassas Yeganeh, Y., & Jafari, V. (2008). [The role of the audit committee in non-profit units of public sector (Persian)]. Hesabdar, 23(196), 73-7. https://hesabdar.iica.ir/articles/hesabdar-1387-4-196-73-77
Hedayati Zafarghandi, M. (2017). [The role and function of the Court of Audit in the realization of financial supervision (Persian)]. International Journal of Nations Research, 2(18), 45-60. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/373670/
Hsu, P. F., & Chen, B. Y. (2007). Developing and implementing a selection model for bedding chain retail store franchisee using Delphi and fuzzy AHP. Quality & Quantity, 41(2), 275-90. [DOI:10.1007/s11135-006-9004-z]
Kalantar Mehrjerdi, A., Ghasyari, H., & Tavassoli, R. (2017). [Effectiveness of public audit (Persian)]. Journal of Research in Management and Accounting, 3(22). https://civilica.com/doc/721851/
Kahraman. C. (2009). Fuzzy multi-criteria decision making: Theory and applications with recent developments. Springer optimization and its applications. Vol. 16. Boston, MA: Springer.
Keršuliene, V., Zavadskas, E. K., & Turskis, Z. (2010). Selection of rational dispute resolution method by applying new step‐wise weight assessment ratio analysis (Swara). Journal of Business Economics and Management, 11(2), 243-58. [DOI:10.3846/jbem.2010.12]
Kheyrollahi, F., Karami, A., & Hafezi, F. (2015). [Performance-based budgeting and its impact on government performance (Persian)]. Paper presented at The First National and International Conference on Management and Accounting Iran, Hamadan, Iran, 5 December 2015. https://civilica.com/doc/471897/
Khodabakhshi, H., & Jabbari, M. (2007). [The need for monitoring before and during spending in a performance-based budgeting system (Persian)]. Economic Journal, 15(1-2), 53-66. http://ejip.ir/article-1-726-fa.html
Kordestani, G. R., & Alavi, S. M. (2014). [The role of internal audit in improving public sector management (Persian)]. Internal Auditors, 1(3), 21-8. https://www.magiran.com/paper/1320270
Krippendorff, K. (2018). Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications. https://books.google.com/books?id=FixGDwAAQBAJ&dq
Mahmoudkhani, M., & Ahmadi, R. (2018). [Performance auditing: A public sector approach (Persian)]. Journal of Accounting, Accountability and Society Interests, 8(2), 71-98. [DOI:10.22051/IJAR.2017.15594.1302]
Manyaga, C. B., Muturi, W., & Oluoch, O. (2020). Board gender diversity and financial performance of commercial banks in Kenya. Journal of Finance and Accounting, 8(1), 1-10. http://www.sciepub.com/jfa/abstract/11319
Mauro, S. G., Cinquini, L., & Pianezzi, D. (2019). New public management between reality and illusion: Analysing the validity of performance-based budgeting. The British Accounting Review, April, 100825. [DOI:10.1016/j.bar.2019.02.007]
Mayne, J. W., Zapico-Goñi, E. Z. (2017). Monitoring performance in the public sector: Future directions from international experience. New York: Routledge. https://books.google.com/books?id=zD4rDwAAQBAJ&dq
Mayne, J. W., Zapico-Goñi, E. (2007). Monitoring performance in the public sector: Future directions from international experience. New York: Routledge. https://www.routledge.com/Monitoring-Performance-in-the-Public-Sector-Future-Directions-from-International/Mayne-Zapico-Goni/p/book/9781412806329
Mehdi Fard, M. R., & Shabani, S. (2015). [Indicators and approaches governing the public sector financial supervision system (Persian)]. Hesabras, (77), 138-44. http://www.hesabras.com/fa/article/268
Mkasiwa, T. A. (2019). Budgeting and monitoring functions of the Tanzanian Parliament. Journal of Accounting in Emerging Economies, 9(3), 386-406. [DOI:org/10.1108/JAEE-11-2018-0120]
Moullin, M. (2017). Improving and evaluating performance with the Public Sector Scorecard. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 66(4), 442-58. [DOI:10.1108/IJPPM-06-2015-0092]
Mosavi, S. F., Azar, A., Rajabzadeh, A., & Khadivar, A. (2018). [Designing model for performance-based budget using fuzzy cognitive mapping and software systems methodology and fuzzy topsis (Persian)]. Management Research in Iran, 22(1), 299-322. http://mri.modares.ac.ir/article-19-15378-fa.html
Nakhaei, K., Hosseinpour, M., Barzegaran, A. R., & Kharashadizadeh, A. (2018). [Investigating the impact of performance auditing for justice and performing social responsibilities of executive systems in the public sector (Persian)]. Journal of Human Sciences Research, 4(8), 91-116. https://civilica.com/doc/803300/
Nazari Chamaki, F., Jenkins, G. P., & Hashemi, M. (2019). Social impact bonds: Implementation, evaluation, and monitoring. International Journal of Public Administration, 42(4), 289-97. [DOI:10.1080/01900692.2018.1433206]
Nazaripour, M. (2017). [The necessity of establishment of performance audit from the viewpoint of public sector auditors (Persian)]. Journal of Governmental Accounting, 3(2), 79-92. http://gaa.journals.pnu.ac.ir/article_4588.html
Nasi, G., Cucciniello, M., & Degara, V. (2018). Evaluation of innovation performance in the public sector: A systematic review of studies. In E. Borgonovi, E. Anessi-Pessina, & C. Bianchi (Eds.), Outcome-Based Performance Management in the Public Sector. System Dynamics for Performance Management. Vol 2. (pp. 203-224). Cham: Springer. [DOI:10.1007/978-3-319-57018-1_11]
Noroozi, H., & Sajadi, H. (2017). [Performance audit and improvement of the quality and efficiency of the activities of the executive agencies (Persian)]. Economics, Financial Management and Accounting Studies, 2(1/4), 114-33. http://irijournals.ir/journals/02-Economics/v2-i4-1-winter95/paper10.pdf
Ojok, J., & Basheka, B. C. (2016). Measuring the effective role of public sector monitoring and evaluation in promoting good governance in Uganda: Implications from the ministry of local government. Africa’s Public Service Delivery & Performance Review, 4(3), 410-39. [DOI:10.4102/apsdpr.v4i3.122]
Park, J. H. (2019). Does citizen participation matter to performance-based budgeting? Public Performance & Management Review, 42(2), 280-304. [DOI:10.1080/15309576.2018.1437050]
Patrucco, A. S., Luzzini, D., & Ronchi, S. (2016). Evaluating the effectiveness of public procurement performance management systems in local governments. Local Government Studies, 42(5), 739-61. [DOI:10.1080/03003930.2016.1181059]
Premchand, A., Khakbaz, A., & Ghsemi, M. (2005). [Public financial accountability (Persian)]. Majlis va Pajouhesh, 13(51), 299-333. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/185624/
Rangriz, H., Naveh Ebrahim, A. R., Arasteh, H. R., & Soltanieh, F. (2017). [Designing the model of strategic competencies of functional managers with thematic analysis (Persian)]. Managing Education in Organizations, 6(1), 9-49. http://journalieaa.ir/article-1-87-fa.html
Saibani, A. R., & Jafari, Z. (2017). [The position of financial oversight in constitution and its review in Guardian Council votes (Persian)]. International Journal of Nations Research, 2(17), 71-87. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/369699
Slukhai, S. (2011). Monitoring and evaluation as tools for enhancing public expenditure management in Ukraine. Financial Theory and Practice, 35(2), 217-39. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/227448264
Tzeng, G. H., & Teng, J. Y. (1993). Transportation investment project selection with fuzzy multiobjectives. Transportation Planning and Technology, 17(2), 91-112. [DOI:10.1080/03081069308717504]
Wang, J., Ma, Q., & Liu, H. C. (2021). A meta-evaluation model on science and technology project review experts using IVIF-BWM and MULTIMOORA. Expert Systems with Applications, 168, 114236. [DOI:10.1016/j.eswa.2020.114236]
Wilson, J. P. (2001). Human resource development: Learning & training for individuals & organizations. London: Kogan Page. https://books.google.com/books?id=zpNc_GZIiikC&source=gbs_navlinks_s
Wu, C. H., & Fang, W. C. (2011). Combining the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and the fuzzy Delphi method for developing critical competences of electronic commerce professional managers. Quality & Quantity, 45(4), 751-68. [DOI:10.1007/s11135-010-9425-6]
Yang, Ch., & Northcott, D. (2019). Together we measure: Improving public service outcomes via the co-production of performance measurement. Public Money & Management, 39(4), 253-61. [DOI:10.1080/09540962.2019.1592906]
Yang, S. B., & Torneo, A. R. (2016). Government performance management and evaluation in South Korea: History and current practices. Public Performance & Management Review, 39(2), 279-96. [DOI:10.1080/15309576.2015.1108767]
Yıldız, C. (2017). Monitoring and evaluation systems for urban infrastructure services: A comparison of the systems applied by Turkish authorities and international financing institutions [MSc. thesis]. Çankaya/Ankara: Middle East Technical University. https://open.metu.edu.tr/handle/11511/26898
Zaruni, D., & Jalalian, A. (2018). [Favorable model of financial supervision of the Court of Audit (Persian)]. Knowledge of Law and Finance, 2(4), 39-50. https://malieh.dmk.ir/article-1-60-fa.html